Patsy's Pizza--Murray Hill

Claim
marker

509 Third Avenue (at Between 34th and 35th Streets.)
New York, NY 10016

marker
(212) 689-7500
Incorrect info? Correct your listing
Reviews
( 1 )
( 5 )
( 1 )
( 0 )
( 1 )

Best

My husband and I are from the Seattle area and were looking for a really good New York pizza experience. We were not disappointed at Patsy's. We had no wait and the service was ...

Worst

we've been to this place 2 times. could'nt believe it was this bad, so we tried and tried. no more trying here. i would rather spend my money on a care package for starving eth...

never go to this place 6/8/2009

we've been to this place 2 times. could'nt believe it was this bad, so we tried and tried. no more trying here. i would rather spend my money on a care package for starving ethiopians. last time we went i didnt even leave a tip. food and service were horrible. they need to get rid of the entire wait staff. letting go of the cooks isnt a bad idea either. steer clear of this place. it says this place has been in business forever. dont know how, except people like me cant believe its that bad and try again... Pros: no pro's here Cons: everything more
Reply | Report abuse |

Love the thin crust... 7/28/2007

We went to Patsy's about a month ago and had pizza. We love the pizza here...not too much sauce, not too much cheese, thin crust. The crust was a little burnt in a few spots, but certainly did not take away from the otherwise great pizza. Service was ok. It took a little while for them to take our order and we had to wait a little too long for a second glass of water. Overall, I would certainly recommend the place, especially for the price, if you are just having pizza. Pros: great thin crust pizza Cons: service could have been a bit better more
Reply | Report abuse |

Good Pizza 8/1/2006

My friends and I stop here for pizza before hitting the Kips Bay movie theater. We always enjoy the pizza. Some great thin crust!! I've never had any of the dinners. The service is pretty good. No complaints! Pros: Really good thin crust pizza Cons: maybe a bit pricey? more
Reply | Report abuse |

Good pizza, disgusting pasta 7/3/2005

I've eaten at Patsy's throughout the city a few times- tonight was the worst. We had a waiter who could care less that my sausage/garlic/rigatoni dish tasted like vaseline, it was probably the grossest pasta dish I've ever tasted. AND he told us, quite promptly, when we asked him to take it back, that we would be charged for it. The pizza was 'okay-' but it is frankly, hard to mess up pizza. you just have good dough and throw fresh ingredients on it. But that pasta dish- and the rude/inconsiderate waiter- unacceptable. I won't be eating here again in the future. LL more
Reply | Report abuse |

Wondeful experience! 12/16/2004

My husband and I are from the Seattle area and were looking for a really good New York pizza experience. We were not disappointed at Patsy's. We had no wait and the service was very good - took a little while to get our pizza but considering they brought us bread and salad before, we didn't mind. They even refilled our water glasses like 4 times during our meal - and we weren't there all that long. I definitely recommend Patsy's to anyone who's wanting a really good pizza in Midtown Manhattan. Pros: food, service, atmosphere more
Reply | Report abuse |

VERY GOOD PLACE 6/27/2003

Although you do have to wait some time for the food it is worth it nice place very good service great pizza would recommend Pros: great food, nice service, fair prices Cons: a bit of a wait more
Reply | Report abuse |

Pizza! Pizza! 1/3/2003

I've enjoyed every trip I've made to Patsy's, but I can see why others might be put off. Yes, it's crowded and yes the service can be ""not so nice"" at all times. This is NY, it happens. If you can't tolerate slow service at a pizza place, then spend more money elsewhere. Patsy's has great salads - I prefer the arugula salad. Their prosciutto pizza is my personal favorite ($2 for each topping). Expect a crowd while waiting, but they seat quickly. Pros: Salads, Pizza Cons: Inconsistent Service, Waits more
Reply | Report abuse |

Itlain food... Family Style! 8/25/2002

Great atmosphere and good food describe Patsy's Family Style Pasta dishes and Brick Oven Pizza. Unlike most whole in the wall Pizza places, you can taste the real Olive Oil in their pizza's... not some greasy corn oil. Perfect for a date or a family outing. It's at a great location with plenty of bar and lounges nearby to enjoy afterwards. Pros: Good Value Cons: Crowded more
Reply | Report abuse |
< Previous 1 Next >
Menu for Patsy's Pizza--Murray Hill


Summer SALE!!!:
15% OFF all yearly plans
Use year15 at checkout. Expires 1/1/2021
Additional information
  • Hours: Sun-Thu 12pm-11pm Fri-Sat 12pm-12am.
  • Neighborhoods: Midtown, Murray Hill
badge