Black Duck

Claim
marker

122 E 28th St (at nr. Lexington Ave.)
New York, NY 10016

marker
(212) 204-5240
Incorrect info? Correct your listing
Photos
Black Duck - New York, NY
Black Duck - New York, NY
Reviews
( 30 )
( 13 )
( 9 )
( 2 )
( 2 )

Best

I went to this restaurant on December 18, 2009 with my co-workers for a holiday dinner. The chef, Hector Tice, who came out and introduced himself, gave us a breakdown of the me...

Worst

It is shocking how in such a competitive restaurant market food (and service) can be so average. The $28 halibut accompanied by a mound of starch (called risotto) can be consumed ...

Good Food, Great Service! 4/7/2004

Took 16 business clients for dinner 03 April. 17 people swelled to 20. BD staff quickly accommodated and was pleasant througout. Food was good, but, in the business environment, the service was what really counted. I could tell they rarely had a large party, but they gave it their best and made it a very pleasant evening. I appreciated the extra care and attention -- Great work, guys! Pros: Outstanding Service, Friendly more
Reply | Report abuse |

killer menu 11/9/2003

I have walked by this restaurant twice a day for almost a year.It seemed Extremely slow in the begining and now the exact opposite.I went in for the first time this past Saturday w/ four friends.They had about a ten minute wait for a table.When we sat we were greeted immediately.Then came the food the apps were awesome(chinese crab salad)!Three of us had the seared rack of lamb........oh my God! awesome,awesome,awesome. Way to go guys! Pros: beautiful music, fresh amazing food, young and fun Cons: about to be found out more
Reply | Report abuse |

Just Ducky! 11/6/2003

I recently visited the Black Duck with a group of 9--and they now have 9 more fans! Among us, we ordered a large sampling of the menu, and everyone thoroughly enjoyed their meal. (Read: clean plate club) The service is extremely friendly and attentive, and the atmosphere gives it that relaxing, neighborhood vibe. Go now. Go often. Pros: Great Food, Great Service, Great Atmosphere more
Reply | Report abuse |

Disappointed 10/12/2003

I hate to rain on the Black Duck parade, but I was not all that overwhelmed. Agreed that the dining room is nice and the tunes are good, but I can only rate the food slightly above average. Had the mushroom salad which was ok, but the asparagus were warm (nice) and the mushrooms freezing (bad). Then onto the pork chop for me and the duck for my companion. Pork overcooked but flavorful and the duck very fatty. Service was prompt and friendly, but overall, for dishes in the mid-$20s, I'd rather go to an Artisanal or Park Bistro. Pros: Service, Setting Cons: Prices, Variety more
Reply | Report abuse |

Great American Bistro 9/25/2003

American Fusion food at it's finest.The chef being a mere 25 years old,has a bright future ahead.Every dish we had was fresh and had outstanding flavors.Young fun staff w/ live music on the weekends.Some favorite dishes(mushroom salad,duck confit,seared tuna,espresso rubbed filet migon) Pros: food, lively, food more
Reply | Report abuse |

fantastic 9/13/2003

Went to the Black Duck for my girlfriend's birthday after reading the reviews on Citysearch. I thought the extremely positive rating might have been inflated by overzealous diners, but they are anything but exagerations. While we're not seasoned reviewers, this was the best meal of our lives. In fact, the entire dining experience was outstanding. The Espresso Rubbed Filet Mignon was outstanding. Extremely tasty dish. My girlfriend's fish (sorry I don't remember the name) was in a jalepeno sauce not too sweet or too hot. Fantastic. The Bananas and Fruit Foster took my breath away. Add this to the outstanding atmosphere and very chill live Brazillian jazz (on weekends) and I would not hesitate to recomend this to anyone looking for a wonderful dining experience. Pros: FOOD!, not crowded, dining experience Cons: none at all more
Reply | Report abuse |

So Good! 8/13/2003

Had a wonderful dinner here last night. I had the espresso rubbed fliet mignon and my boyfriend had the most amazing pork chops. The dessert completely lived up to the rest of the meal. They have a very extensive drink list as well as great music and a nice, relaxing atmosphere. Would definitely go back! Pros: drinks, good food, music more
Reply | Report abuse |

Awesome 6/24/2003

If you live in the city,eat at the Black Duck.Simply put everything is Amazing,from the hospitable staff,the live music,and the wonderully presented fresh food.Awesome New York find!!! Pros: live music, great american cuisne more
Reply | Report abuse |

Amazing Grammercy Find 6/17/2003

I was recently turned on to the Black Duck, for one of thier 5 dollar martinis at happy hour. Last week I decided to sit for dinner w/ a few friends, it was incredible. The Foie Gras was simply to die for. My Girlfriend raved over the burger, while my friend said the halibut was fresh from the boat. The intimate setting and gracious staff made for a perfect evening. Don't miss this spot even if you have to travel! Pros: 5 dollar martinis, Awesome Hostess, Still a Secret Cons: Still a Secret more
Reply | Report abuse |

A Delight! 6/11/2003

I paid my second visit to Black Duck last night after a excellent meal several months back. The restaurant didn't let me down. The food is artfully prepared and a wonderful treat for the taste buds. An excellent wine selection complements every bite. The wait staff is attentive, but not obtrusive. The restaurant is an excellent example of what makes New York the dining capital of the world... I chose the Black Duck as the venue for a romantic meal with new special lady in my life. I'm very glad I did! Pros: Creative Menu, Wonderful Flavors, Romantic more
Reply | Report abuse |

Gem for the Palate 6/8/2003

The Black Duck was a tremendous surprise. The food was outstanding and the service was tops. My wife and I purposely tried varying dishes and all were prepared artistically and with a flare your palate will not soon forget. This place is a treasure, but keep it quiet so my table will always be available. Pros: Dish Selection, Delectable Food, Jazz Music Bonus Cons: I live outside NYC more
Reply | Report abuse |

The Best Place in NYC! 5/26/2003

I would highly recommend this wonderful restaurant! The food is not your ordinary ""meat & potatoes."" The dishes are artistically created with a flavor that is truly extraordinary and pleasing to the palate. The ambiance is serene and relaxing. I can't wait to go back and have recommended this delightful place to all my friends and colleagues! Pros: Reasonable Priced, Relaxing, Good Parking Cons: None, None, None more
Reply | Report abuse |

Not your usual hotel bar/restaurant 5/16/2003

Tired of the ridiculous lines at Houston's, Les Halles, and Dos Caminos? Anthony Bourdain may not work here, but the food is a definate cut above! Try the espresso rubbed filet mignon - it's a generous portion, done to perfection, and the ""espresso butter"" topping is sublime. I've tried over half the menu and each time my meal has been memorable. Even the desserts deserve a standing ""O."" With an atmosphere that is is relaxing and spacious and a staff that is friendly and inviting - this place is a real find. Bravo! Pros: live music, great bartender, Van Gogh Vodkas more
Reply | Report abuse |

Wow 2/9/2003

The Black Duck, hidden in the Park South Hotel, is great. The food was fresh and well-prepared, although the portion sizes were rather small (especially for the money). While the theme is nautical, the decor is tastefully done, comfortable and I dare say, romantic. Tables were far enough away from each other to ensure solitary dining, andoOn weekends they have live music. If you can, try to snag a booth near the back. Service was attentive and friendly, whether the hostess, waitstaff or bartenders. The Black Duck is a great date place, whether going for dinner or just for a drink at their huge, antique-ish bar. Pros: Food, Decor, Service Cons: Small Portions more
Reply | Report abuse |

A Real Find 1/10/2003

One of the best meals I have had in New York. The duck confit appetizer is incredible and I usually do not like duck. Brined pork chop entree was even tastier. Strange that there are so few customers. Pros: excellent food more
Reply | Report abuse |

A Lovely find! 1/9/2003

Tucked away cutely beneath the Park South Hotel on 28th street, you will surely miss it if you don't look closely. It is a superb, laid back place with fantastic food, attentive service, and a nice feel. The 1 chicken entree was superb, and the blackened mahi mahi was quite tasty. This place is a real find - I hope it stays open! more
Reply | Report abuse |
< Previous 1 2 3 Next >
Menu for Black Duck


Summer SALE!!!:
15% OFF all yearly plans
Use year15 at checkout. Expires 1/1/2021

One of Manhattan's Best-Kept Secrets

Editorial

  • The Scene
    Named for Prohibition's notoriously elusive rum-running ship, this quiet, hidden refuge within Murray Hill's Park South Hotel still slips under the radar. A collection of stormy...

  • 6/14/2005 Provided by Citysearch
Additional information
  • Hours: Daily 5:30pm-11pm
  • Payments: Visa, Master Card, American Express, Diner's Club, Discover
  • Neighborhoods: Kips Bay, Midtown
badge