I've gone here twice, and each time the food has not disappointed. Everything tastes freshly prepared, and the waiters know the details of everything on the menu. The service can be pretty slow, so don't expect to be in and out of there too quickly. The warm, dimly lit atmosphere makes it a great place to go on a cold night. It can be a little expensive since things like salads are ala carte, but for the most part, it's standard NY prices.
Pros: atmosphere, the salads, the pesto ravioli
Cons: slow service