This is my favorite pizza in the USA. I lived in NYC for one year and tried as many pizza joints as I could, but Anna Maria's was by far my favorite. It was also a favorite of my roommates. All of the pizza is sold ""by the slice"". There are usually about 12-15 varieties to choose from. The slices are large with generous amounts of sauce and toppings. Usually one slice would suffice as my meal. The ingredients are very fresh. I never thought the service was rude, but it is very fast due to the large numbers of patrons. If you are looking for a pleasant, sit-down, dining experience, this is NOT the place to go. The tables are laminated, crowded, and I think rarely cleaned between customers. You order at the counter, but sometimes it is better to take it to go, since the small eating area is often crowded. However, if you are looking for tasty, fresh pizza at a good price, this is the best place.
Pros: Excellent, fresh pizza. Good variety. By the slice. Fun.
Cons: Small eating area. Not pretty.
more