As a transplanted New Yorker, I expect excellent pizza as standard fare. This was not it. Maybe good for fancier topped pies, but for the standard topping pizza I am very disappointed. My pie had rubbery cheese, and an almost cake-like crust. I don't mind a thick crust, but needs to be crispy at least. On a better note the sauce was good. Unfortunately, sauce alone does not make the pie.
The pizza however is much better than the wings, which were just horrid. As some kind of sick joke, along with your soggy, almost sauce-less wings you get a watery version of ranch dressing, which to me tasted exactly like the make it yourself hidden valley ranch. Blue cheese isn't even an option here, or at least wasn't listed on the menu as a substitution for the ranch.
If they can get a better coating of sauce on a crispy wing, along with thick creamy blue cheese, and improve crust just a tad bit, it would probably be a real descent slice. It breaks my heart to rate a locally owned shop this way, as I am a die-hard supporter of places like this...
I know they offer a money back guarantee, but I don't want it back, I just want some descent pizza. Pizza-Nizza, you breaka my heart...
more