With the limited restaurant selections (restaurant being defined as someplace you can actually sit down and eat - and not on the top of a washing machine) in Durham, Libby's is a good choice for a nice meal. While the bar can get crowded with undergraduates on certain weeknights if you get there for a drink early enough, it's enjoyable for the (slightly) older crowd as well. I don't know if I'd try anything to fancy or different on the menu, but if you're looking for a burger or something simple, Libby's is a good bet.
more