Being a small, locally owned business, I had to give Toscana a try. I found their pizza to be way better than Pagliacci, or the other so-so pizza joints. Now, I order from them at least once a week, and it hasn't done my pocket book much damage, either, because their prices are very reasonable.
Pros: delicious, reliable, friendly, budget-friendly
Cons: I just can't get enough of their pizza!