I would rate the location at the Fulton Pier only with "Fair." This is mostly a tourist trap because many traverse the Brooklyn Bridge and this is one of the most noticeable shops they will come across. Granted the ice cream is fairly good but not quite exceptional. Their peaches and cream and butter pecan are quite light in flavor, if that's what you like. I do have to give them credit because they claim to use all natural ingredients. However, this is still worth dropping because there is plenty of seating and the atmosphere is quite nice. Plus, you have great scenery right outside the ice cream shop.
more