Came for a family friend's funeral reception. I have eaten at Sayler's in the past, and was dissapointed then too. I have grown up eating steaks at all kinds of places, and feel that I know what a good steak should taste like. I don't expect anything too fancy, just a good steak and a good potato. If you serve simple food, its fine, just do it well. If you serve a relish tray, serve fresh vegetables, not ones that have curled from sitting in water, or coming pre-cut in the large bags I saw in your kitchen, which smelled funky as I walked by it, by the way. I expect that banquets can be hard to manage, lots of people who all want something from you. I was dissapointed that our drinks arrived so far into the meal that most of us were done with our entrees before they came, and those of us who ordered iced tea were just out of luck, and not offered an alternative. It was like a famine at our table for the first hour before ordering, and then the second as the food trickled in. Our dressings and ""sour cream"" sat on the table for over an hour and a half before we had anything to eat them with. The salad was on its last leg, looking less than fresh with a slice of canned pickled beet that had been out of it's brine for so long it was dry and pasty looking. The dressing was bland and tasteless, even the bleu cheese dressing had no flavor. The famous garlic butter was bitter and full of bluish green particles which I could not identify. (I'm a Chef, so that's sad.) The onion rings were very greasy and surprisingly lacking in flavor, save that of an old fryer in desparate need of cleaning and fresh oil. The menu I was presented with listed Senior Fish and Chips, Senior Chicken, Ground sirloin??, and a Hamburger. I was searching for the ""none of the above"" option. Again, I realize that its a banquet and the menu is limited. I opted for the ground sirloin, begrudgingly, hoping that it would at least be tasty. Our entrees arrived and looked decent. My ground sirloin was greasy and flavorless, being saved only by a decent sear on the outside. Thank god for mushroom sauce, which is something I wouldn't normally eat with a steak. A good steak needs no sauce. I thought, ""There's no way you can screw up a baked potato."" but apparently, sadly, I'm wrong. Your ""sour cream"" topped with freeze dried chives (shame on you) looked fine, but tasted curiously of bacon??! with no bits to be found. The mind boggles at how this can be so. And the taste, terrible. I can excuse some bumps in the road at a banquet meal, but I had the same experience with my first meal here as well, very dissapointing. The highlight of the meal was the bread, which was warm and delicious, with the butter meant for the potato, not the bitter garlic, perhaps because I was so hungry by the time it arrived, and the ice cream which was delicious.
more