Stillwater is a fun place to visit but I have found that the antiques are way over priced. It would probably be a good place to go if you are looking for something unusual, but I wouldn't shop there for most antiques. The parking is horrible. We have found that we have to get there early in the morning to find a parking place that is anywhere near downtown. There are several good restaurants and the river is beautiful so I guess I would recommend Stillwater for sight-seeing only.
Pros: variety
Cons: parking, expensive
more