This is a story of a restaurant with a long history, that quite possibly has outgrown its britches. Early in my career I visited this restaurant and was wowed by the food (5 star easily), but recently I have only been wowed by the prices. Creative menu that is constantly changing, but for whatever reason, the food does not live up to my prior expectations any longer, although it can be hard to maintain perfection for many years.
Bottom Line: Wonderful for visiting tourists, Houston weekenders, or locals. Best seafood on the island.