Dylan Prime Restaurant

Last week I met my date in the bar/lounge and we ordered a bottle of wine & apps... I was told it was a pretty chill scene. The food was good (except for the lobster gnocchi!) and the setting was even-toned and comfortable. It's nothing like your Midtown steakhouse. I was totally expecting the place to be swarming with bankers, but I was pleasantly srprised. Very civilized - very romantic. Next time we'll eat i the dining room, but I have to say, the bar is quite cool! Pros: Steak & Fondue; Wine List Cons: Lobster Gnocchi more

Last week I met my date in the bar/lounge and we ordered a bottle of wine & apps... I was told it was a pretty chill scene. The food was good (except for the lobster gnocchi!) and the setting was even-toned and comfortable. It's nothing like your Midtown steakhouse. I was totally expecting the place to be swarming with bankers, but I was pleasantly srprised. Very civilized - very romantic. Next time we'll eat i the dining room, but I have to say, the bar is quite cool! Pros: Steak & Fondue; Wine List Cons: Lobster Gnocchi more

I recently, went here for a big occaision and was really looking forward to it. I had heard lots of positive things and went in with high expectations. If you are looking for a true steakhouse there are tons of better options in the city. My favorite is the Palm, hands down. Dylan Prime disappointed from the get go. We were seated by the entrance and there was a contant cold draft each time the door was opened. I repeat do not order the 7oz. steak! This steak was the size of mini hamburger! It was a joke of a piece of meat. I sent this piece back and ordered the 11oz for 6 dollars more and it wasn't much bigger. While we waited our sides sat on the table cold. The sides were tiny portions! Mac and cheese tasted good but tiny portion. The creamed spinach was awful, nut pureed and not creamy. The Manager came over and told me that the steak had shrunk because it was ordered medium well! That is hogwash! I have eaten at many steakhouses and had never heard that one. Just admit that the steak size was subpar and that you are sorry! I paid my bill and gave almost 20% as I felt for the waiter! He was not helpful either! I will never go back to this restaurant ever! Pros: taste of food was average Cons: small portions and overpriced! Noisey! more

I recently, went here for a big occaision and was really looking forward to it. I had heard lots of positive things and went in with high expectations. If you are looking for a true steakhouse there are tons of better options in the city. My favorite is the Palm, hands down. Dylan Prime disappointed from the get go. We were seated by the entrance and there was a contant cold draft each time the door was opened. I repeat do not order the 7oz. steak! This steak was the size of mini hamburger! It was a joke of a piece of meat. I sent this piece back and ordered the 11oz for 6 dollars more and it wasn't much bigger. While we waited our sides sat on the table cold. The sides were tiny portions! Mac and cheese tasted good but tiny portion. The creamed spinach was awful, nut pureed and not creamy. The Manager came over and told me that the steak had shrunk because it was ordered medium well! That is hogwash! I have eaten at many steakhouses and had never heard that one. Just admit that the steak size was subpar and that you are sorry! I paid my bill and gave almost 20% as I felt for the waiter! He was not helpful either! I will never go back to this restaurant ever! Pros: taste of food was average Cons: small portions and overpriced! Noisey! more

I a business dinner there. The food was good but I'm not a steak lover. Great for Business meetings and drinks, but other than that , that's it foe me. When you are spending money in these type of places people are general nice and provide good service Pros: Business meetings Cons: depends who you speak to regarding $$$ more

I a business dinner there. The food was good but I'm not a steak lover. Great for Business meetings and drinks, but other than that , that's it foe me. When you are spending money in these type of places people are general nice and provide good service Pros: Business meetings Cons: depends who you speak to regarding $$$ more

I'm a carnivore, so I was really looking forward to my steak night out in NYC. I ordered the carpetbagger,... more

I'm a carnivore, so I was really looking forward to my steak night out in NYC. I ordered the carpetbagger,... more

I'm a carnivore, so I was really looking forward to my steak night out in NYC. I ordered the carpetbagger, which was a cut of filet mignon stuffed ... more

I personally believe the decor and atmosphere at Dylan's sister restaurant, Devin Tavern is much better than Dylan. The decor and atmosphere at Dylan is very Plain Jane. The steaks and overall food at Dylan is delectible. The service was less than average?our waiter had the personality of a rock. Pros: the steaks Cons: the service and decor more

I personally believe the decor and atmosphere at Dylan's sister restaurant, Devin Tavern is much better than Dylan. The decor and atmosphere at Dylan is very Plain Jane. The steaks and overall food at Dylan is delectible. The service was less than average?our waiter had the personality of a rock. Pros: the steaks Cons: the service and decor more

The lighting here is fantastic. Great date place... everyone looks good under the lighting. The night we went, it seemed like all the Smith Barney employees were eating here. Excellent sound system. Strange selection of music. Did they just play Michael Jackson? The person working coat check looked really depressed. We ignored her. Fondue was fun. Steaks great quality and taste. My husband liked his martini. Our waiter was kind of nervous. He did not seem confident about his recommendations when we asked him. Maybe the staff is tired from having to serve too many jaded bankers? Okay, I'll stop being judgemental. Despite the few staff glitches, had a great time. Hubby and I walked through Tribeca all the way home to the West Village after this very filling meal. Pros: lighting, decor, steaks, cocktails, sound system, location Cons: depressed coatcheck girl, nervous waiter, too many bankers more

The lighting here is fantastic. Great date place... everyone looks good under the lighting. The night we went, it seemed like all the Smith Barney employees were eating here. Excellent sound system. Strange selection of music. Did they just play Michael Jackson?\r \r The person working coat check looked really depressed. We ignored her.\r \r Fondue was fun. Steaks great quality and taste. My husband liked his martini. \r \r Our waiter was kind of nervous. He did not seem confident about his recommendations when we asked him. Maybe the staff is tired from having to serve too many jaded bankers? Okay, I'll stop being judgemental.\r \r Despite the few staff glitches, had a great time. Hubby and I walked through Tribeca all the way home to the West Village after this very filling meal. Pros: lighting, decor, steaks, cocktails, sound system, location Cons: depressed coatcheck girl, nervous waiter, too many bankers more

Recently went with a large group from work. Everything we ordered was terrific. You must try the fondue and macaroni and cheese with lobster and truffle sauce. Delicious! Great service and drinks as well. Bit pricey, but worth it. Pros: Steak, seafood, ALL FOOD Cons: Can get kind of loud more

Recently went with a large group from work. Everything we ordered was terrific. You must try the fondue and macaroni and cheese with lobster and truffle sauce. Delicious! Great service and drinks as well. Bit pricey, but worth it. Pros: Steak, seafood, ALL FOOD Cons: Can get kind of loud more

what a fantastic Restaurant. Been many times. I find it hard to steer away from the rib eye (try it with the black truffle beurre blanc), but I have tried the surf and turf WOW, also the beef wellington,(also available in mini form on the fantastic bar menu). The service is great, well informed and very enthusiastic, great wine reccomendations. The bartenders are amazing!! try the signature Manhattan, also the dessert cocktails are out of this world. Too many thing to try, bring lots of friends and try a little of each. Calling for a reservation is a dream, and then after a few visits, the very attentive door staff recognised us and were very accomodating, ( our party increased at the last moment) Go there for a great fun date or somewhere to bring your parents, this restaurant has something for everyone including vegetarians. Cant wait to go again and to try their new restaurant Devin Tavern more

what a fantastic Restaurant. Been many times. I find it hard to steer away from the rib eye (try it with the black truffle beurre blanc), but I have tried the surf and turf WOW, also the beef wellington,(also available in mini form on the fantastic bar menu). The service is great, well informed and very enthusiastic, great wine reccomendations. The bartenders are amazing!! try the signature Manhattan, also the dessert cocktails are out of this world. Too many thing to try, bring lots of friends and try a little of each. Calling for a reservation is a dream, and then after a few visits, the very attentive door staff recognised us and were very accomodating, ( our party increased at the last moment) Go there for a great fun date or somewhere to bring your parents, this restaurant has something for everyone including vegetarians. Cant wait to go again and to try their new restaurant Devin Tavern more

hey - the steak is ok- but lets get to the point- management doesnt give a hoot about you- when you get up, someone else will shuffle in- so you spent $100 on a meal- big deal- you got it now go-not happy about service or treatment- thats your problem- THEY don't need you- as long as fools are willing to put up with subpar service-there will always be some fool spending money there-THIS fool won't Pros: decent steak Cons: terrible service more

hey - the steak is ok- but lets get to the point- management doesnt give a hoot about you-\r when you get up, someone else will shuffle in- so you spent $100 on a meal- big deal- you got it now go-not happy about service or treatment- thats your problem- THEY don't need you- as long as fools are willing to put up with subpar service-there will always be some fool spending money there-THIS fool won't Pros: decent steak Cons: terrible service more

The steak here is excellent. I personally like fattier cuts so i chose a fattier steak. It was done to perfection as requested: medium rare. We had some mid-range priced Amarone wine which was DELICIOUS. Even though the steak is out of sight, I think it was surpassed by my love for the wine. Our waiter was attentive, patient and went painstakingly out of his way to make our meal special. The ony thing I was disappointed with was the decor. It thought it would be modern but, it's not. IT's pretty much done like an old boy's club restaurant. The highlight of hte decor is the beautiful clear, ground floor wine cellar they have. Dylan Prime will break the bank but, you actually might not mind. more