I've been going to the CIP for several years. Yes, it can get smoky, but it's in a cellar, so, duh. The beer selection is terrific--a lot of local and craft brews--and while many people were worried about how the atmosphere and crowd might change when hard liquor was added, it really has only opened up more options in terms of the libation menu. The food menu, while it hasn't much changed, is still good, solid pub grub. The staff is friendly (as long as you don't try and pull attitude on them--be a jerk, especially to other patrons, and you'll be out of there in a heartbeat) and while it does seem like the customers are getting younger every year, is still just as welcoming to the regulars as it always has been.
Pros: Great beer selection, Cool staff, Good prices
Cons: Can get smoky, Only 1 good pinball, Parking can be iffy
more