My boyfriend and I made a reservation for Valentines Day at the Black duck and were extremely disappointed.  From the $85 per person prefix menu, the appetizers, yellowtail, clams, & scallops were pretty good.  However the entrees were awful.  The steak was cooked well, while we ordered it medium rare.  The lobster was so overcooked it tasted like a sponge.  We were already an hour and a 1/2 into dinner and didn't want to send the food back.  I haven't seen the regular menu, but will not go back to try it.
Pros:  Ambience
Cons:  Food
                        
more