Like the other reviewers, we think this place is very good. The service is good, the fish is fresh and the prices are great. What strikes me as odd from all the other previous reviews is that no one has really mentioned all the more authentic and atypical assorments that they offer. Great selection of yakitori and they also might be the only place uptown (at least that I know of) that serves takoyaki! Of course I like the takoyaki from St. Marks better but for an uptown place, Tatany certainly satisfies without me having to travel far.
Pros: menu selection, price
more