Paolo's Gelato Italiano Ice

Claim
marker

1025 Virginia Ave NE
Atlanta, GA 30306

marker
(404) 607-0055
Incorrect info? Correct your listing
Related categories:

Food & Dining

Photos
Paolo's Gelato Italiano Ice - Atlanta, GA
Paolo's Gelato Italiano Ice - Atlanta, GA
Paolo's Gelato Italiano Ice - Atlanta, GA
Reviews
( 17 )
( 5 )
( 3 )
( 6 )
( 8 )

Best

Undoubtedly the best gelato in ATL. Sure, Paolo has all kinds of sweet treats on display (I'm curious about the chocolate pyramids) but don't get distracted -- you want the gel...

Worst

Besides the rude lady who makes you feel like you're not even welcome in the store which is backwards, this place is the only place I know of in Atlanta that sells Gelato unless s...

1st and Last Visit 2/21/2011

Went there for the 1st time yesterday and will Never go back again! The woman behind the counter was so RUDE I can't even remember what the gelato tasted like. Should have read the reviews 1st . Forced to give 1 Star because a rating is required. Should be Zero. more
Reply | Report abuse |

If I close my eyes, I can pretend I'm in Italy... 10/22/2010

Undoubtedly the best gelato in ATL. Sure, Paolo has all kinds of sweet treats on display (I'm curious about the chocolate pyramids) but don't get distracted -- you want the gelato. I am passionate about the stracciatella gelato, which is like vanilla, only creamier and infused with bits of sweet chocolate. There are other flavors, but I need only one... The first time I ever had stracciatella was in Italy, and I completely fell in love. Now when I want to remember those sunny days along the coast of Italy, I make the drive to Paolo's. Parking in VA-HI is a pain, but I guess it's easier (and cheaper) than a flight to Europe. And if I close my eyes, I can pretend I'm in Italy... more
Reply | Report abuse |

You must be kidding me ... Paolo's sucks. 7/11/2010

The most overrated establishment in Atlanta. We just got back from 4 weeks in Italy and this ""gelato"" is not as good as the worst gelato we had in Italy (and we tried 5 different flavors). We also tried their Tiramisu and Profiteroles ... horrible too. Tiramisu tasted like congealed egg nog and the Profiteroles tasted like poor supermarket products. I cannot believe that anyone who ever had real Italian gelato would like this place. I would never bring my Italian friends here because they would hate it. I wanted this place to be good ... too bad. Baskin and Robbins, Ben and Jerrys have better desserts and are less expensive. Pros: It has nice decor. Cons: Terrible gelato and desserts, expensive, long lines. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Not as Italian as he claims 7/8/2010

Any real Italian person (especially someone like me who grew up in the hart of Gelato) will tell you this taste nothing like real Italian gelato.... I found the ingredients were not fresh at all, gelato was overpriced and service was soo and soooo.....very disappointing......it seems to me they are cutting corners thinking perhaps that over here no one will know the difference....not so fast.... Pros: None really Cons: overprices and not gelato more
Reply | Report abuse |

Fabulous gelato in the heart of the Highlands 3/28/2010

Tucked away in the adorable Virginia Highlands area, Paolo's is a quaint little shop specializing in Italian Gelato. Behind the gorgeous case of colorful gelato, you'll find a friendly face to help you choose the flavor of your choice, or sample a few if you can't quite decide. With choices ranging from Amaretto to Green Tea to Rosemary, it can be a tough decision, though, no matter what you decide I'm sure you'll be pleased. Stroll over to Paolo's after dinner one night and sample a gelato. You won't be disappointed. more
Reply | Report abuse |

I am not coming back. 9/14/2009

Besides the rude lady who makes you feel like you're not even welcome in the store which is backwards, this place is the only place I know of in Atlanta that sells Gelato unless someone else out there can let me know. As for the taste, I wouldn't say this is the best Gelato. It just doesn't have the creamy texture, and I wouldn't say this is authentic either. Given the taste/price, I personally don't think it's worth it and you would probably be better off at some regular ice cream place that charges less as well. All this combined with the lady who was obviously irritated at me asking a couple questions, and it just makes for an overall unpleasant experience. Thus, I won't be coming back here again. Pros: Cute store Cons: Rude lady bewware more
Reply | Report abuse |

an ice cream store posing as a gelato store 4/24/2009

I was sold a scoop of ice cream for 5.50 that they tried to pass off as gelato.--------------------------------When I went there, there was a long line and the guy that owns it or whatever was behind the counter. He has a video playing of all these video clips from news channels and the food network coming to the shop. There is so much hype and since most people don't really know what gelato is supposed to be like they believe the hype and say its awesome gelato. In reality its just good ice cream.----------------------------------I think this guy makes real gelato for when he is being covered by the media, the customers come rolling in, he saves money by making ice cream instead of gelato, sells it for gelato prices (5 bucks), people unknowingly just accept that it is gelato and he makes a killing.-------------------------------If you want amazing real gelato then get on 85N and drive two hours to Greenville in SC and go to Luna Rosa:(web address) (lunarosagelato) Pros: store looks nice Cons: its not gelato more
Reply | Report abuse |

AWFUL SERVICE-cute decor 4/20/2009

I have been trying to go to Paolo's for the past 4 months; however, since their hours are so strange, it never seemed to work out. I had lunch at George's on Sunday and then remembered that Paolo's is right around the corner so I headed in for some yummy gelato. The decor of the store is soo cute that I immediately felt drawn in; however, the woman behind the counter NEVER acknowledged my presence and when I started asking her about the flavors, I got one word responses with not even a glimmer of a smile. The pistachio gelato was tasty..but definiteley not worth the $5 price tag or the poor service!! I will NOT be returning to Paolo's again. Too bad since it has such potential! Pros: Great decor...decent gelato Cons: Rude help! more
Reply | Report abuse |

Fools the Eye- Overpriced and Unfriendly 2/6/2009

This place looks charming from the outside and on the inside. However, I was shocked that they have a one sample rule for gelato tasting. I've been lucky enough to have tasted lots of good gelato in Italy, and throughout the U.S, and have never seen a sign stating one sample per customer. Sampling the gelato flavors is normal. Also, Paolo's gelato was just good- not as creamy as others- just good. It certainly was not worth the $4.50 price tag. I went in January. They did not have that many flavors because demand was low during the cooler months. Hot chocolate is on their menu. I requested one and was told that they did not have any milk to make hot chocolate. So, I ordered a small Italian soda, which cost me $3.50. Soda water and flavoring. Note: Ask the cost before ordering because prices are not listed for their beverages. Actually, don't even bother going in. It is obvious that the owner is not involved in the business, which is sad b/c this place has potential. Pros: Charming Exterior and Interior Cons: Overpriced, Service more
Reply | Report abuse |

Overpriced Publix Deli Fare 3/12/2008

The smell was fantastic, unfortunately the service was s$#* ! The server had terrible people skills and had the personality of a goat ! No interest in making a sale...save your time...you'll wig out trying to find a place to park and then have to take abuse off some minimum wage creton. Pros: quality or freshness Cons: service, parking, ambience more
Reply | Report abuse |

Terrible service! 11/19/2007

The server was so NASTY (read: unprofessional) that my niece who had never experienced Gelato still has not tasted what I think is the best dessert in the world. It would not hurt the business to let people try it. Pros: Beautiful presentation! Cons: Rude service after long wait in line more
Reply | Report abuse |

A must see and do in the heart of VA Highlands 2/25/2007

Excellent personality for what we normally see here in the states. Picture all the ice cream shops, smoothie places and desert places you've been too. Pros: Super deserts. Social scene and no problem waiting. Cons: You'll want to go again and again. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Mad Italian's Pistachio Gelato, Pure Heaven! 2/13/2007

We've been regulars of Paolo's, for a very long time in the Highland's. Even in cold February, it's always a high-energy treat. Cannoloi's, Cups, or Waffle Cone's, it's just the best Gelato in the ATL. Personal favorite is Pistachio. Although Rum Raisin, is a close second. And all the Italian caffene is excellent. And to top it all off, the wild and crazy guy himself, Paolo! Oh, and try the unusual Flower Flavors, like Jasmine. Pros: Best Gelato In The ATL! The Crazy Owner! Cons: Who Cares If There Is No Place To Sit! more
Reply | Report abuse |

Great Cannolis, The Gelato is Nothing Special.......Where's the Seating 10/6/2006

I love the cannoli's.....unbelievably good. Pros: Cannoli Cons: Gelato, No Seating, Long Lines and Slow Service more
Reply | Report abuse |

This place is ROCK !! 10/2/2006

Oh !! Man ~ What a Great Gelato !! Pros: Friendly staffs & Best gelato Cons: Parking (weekend) more
Reply | Report abuse |

Easily the best gelato in the city 6/9/2006

Serving more than a few flavors of gelato, Paolo's in Virgina Highland is a great place to go after dinner for a sweet summer treat. Paolo's has been featured on The Food Network and has also been Zaggats rated, so you won't be taking a chance on a unknown with this one. Paolo's has the traditional gelato flavors as well as a line of soy based and flower flavored gelati. I had the nutella gelato and loved it. But, watch out because this is a cash only establishment and there isn't a lot of standing room in the shop. It is worth the crowd and the hassle of having to make sure you have cash. They also have dog gelato, so you can bring Fifi along for a tasty treat as well. Pros: fantastic gelato Cons: no standing room in the shop, cash only, pay parking near the shop only more
Reply | Report abuse |

Not worth it 5/10/2006

Gelato is average and service is horrible. Just ask for a sample and see how you are treated. I won't be back. Pros: location Cons: no parking, no seating area, bad service more
Reply | Report abuse |

Excellent Itanian Ice 4/18/2006

This has to be the best Gielato outside of Italy. It is not cheap, but it worth every penny, and you get what pay for in taste. You're in Virginia Highlands, and the atmosphere, the dining, the people, are what you visit for. It is the perfect way to end your evening, especially with summer approaching. You will see that many agree as the lines lengthen with the summer heat outside. Pros: taste, flavors, atmosphere Cons: price/size, parking, crowds/summer more
Reply | Report abuse |

Overpriced & Crowded 8/3/2003

The store's location in the Highlands means that there is no space to sit and enjoy your gelato - that is if you can find a parking place. And although the gelato is good, the prices are too high for the little portions. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Yummiest of them all 10/10/2002

Absolutely the best! Creamy and low fat...how can Paolo go wrong. Wonderful and unusual flavors, ie. roses, lavender, ect. The coconut rocks! Cons: parking non existent more
Reply | Report abuse |
< Previous 1 2 Next >
Menu for Paolo's Gelato Italiano Ice


Summer SALE!!!:
15% OFF all yearly plans
Use year15 at checkout. Expires 1/1/2021
Editorial

  • The Scene
    Tiny, charming, and chock-full of whimsy, this instantly likeable gelato and sweets boutique stands out in a neighborhood full of eye-catching shops and restaurants. An enormous...

  • 8/14/2003 Provided by Citysearch
Additional information
  • Payments: Cash
  • Neighborhoods: Northeast, Virginia Highland
badge