When I saw Denise's ranked so high I just had to scratch my head and wonder why. I've been there a few times and never walked away too impressed. If lots of different flavors are your thing, then sure this is the place for you. But let me suggest that you go to Christina's (Inman Square) or Toscanini's (Central Square) for lots of flavors. If it's value you're looking for, I suggest going to Brigham's. The ice cream is not worth what you pay at Denise's. I suppose it is rated highly because it gets a good following from the Tufts students that hang out in Davis Square. Apparently not many of them make it to the other ice cream places around Boston. One good suggestion that isn't in the Top 10 list: Putnam Pantry in Danvers. Load up with tons of gooey toppings. You won't be disappointed!
Pros: good location, lots of flavors
Cons: poor value, nothing special, gruff waitstaff
more