The Crab Shack located on Tybee Island is AMAZING! I recommend the "Sampler" for either one or two (although the two person one is big enough for you to split between 3-4 people depending on how much you really eat), I've been here a million times and it's the only thing I've ever gotten (and most people get) because it's so good. The atmosphere is great, I love eating outside on water or on the front patio by the alligators (yes, they have over 70 live alligators in their little lagoon! They're small though).
The only complaint I have is all the dang stray cats running around everywhere which they can't really help because people keep feeding them and they're too nice to call the pound on them I suppose and the dang palmetto bugs but if you've lived in GA for longer than a day, you know they're a problem everywhere! If you have a problem with either of those though, you can eat inside and it takes care of both problems as you won't find either inside the restaurant and you can still see outside since it's all bamboo and screening.
The food's great, the drinks are great and the prices aren't too bad, a little pricey but for seafood and especially of that calibur, The Crab Shack can't be beat!
more