I took my car to MAC for repair after a fender bender. I've read a lot of the reviews and I'm not saying they aren't correct, but I really had a pleasant experience.
Richard worked with my insurance company, and my car looks beautiful. I was out of town when my car was ready and explained to Richard that I was in a pickle. Instead of charging me for storage (as the policy indicates) he let me keep it in a garage, free of charge, something he certainly did not need to do.
He pointed out that I needed new tires, and he was right. I was told soon after that my tires were not going to pass inspection.
My insurance payed for my repairs, so I don't know about pricing, but comparative shopping is really the consumers duty.
All and all, I would recommend MAC.
more