My fiance and I tried Fish the other night, straying from our usual BYOB picks. While the food was decent, the entire experience was nothing to rave about. With 2 drinks, 2 appetizers, 2 entrees, and 1 dessert, our bill was $130 before tip. Nothing was overly memorable, except that my mango margarita tasted exactly like my fiance's grapefruit martini, and both were served sans straw or decorative/edible garnish. For $9 a pop, I want a drink with some effort. The space is small (converted rowhouse) and seating is tight, which is more in line with the city's casual BYOBs, but the pricing is right up there with a Steven Starr--minus the atmosphere, attitude, and glitz that you know you are paying with him. Good food, not worth the money. We would have been better off at Mercato or Melagrano, where we would at least have been in good spirits from the $12 bottle of wine we brought.\r
Pros: Food is good
Cons: Price, tight seating
more