My wife and I have dined here many times and are always satisfied with the food, atmosphere, and service. It may not be the best Italian food you have ever tasted, but it is good, especially the Pasta Carbonara. The atmosphere is usually quiet, dim and romantic. The service is impeccable. Everything is reliable enough for us to take guests when they are visiting town. I am not sure what the other reviewers experienced, as the prices are typical for Manhattan.
Pros: atmosphere, reliable
Cons: very good food, but not outstanding
more