Virgil's was recommended to me by a Manhattan local. It's casual BBQ and they take reservations! The Front Desk and wait service are polite, kind, and patient. The whole atmosphere is very welcoming and they do a good job accomodating people without reservations. There are a lot of good tables, I recommend dining upstairs if you can. Menu is big with many interesting choices. Biscuits and gravy, pulled pork, crab po'boy, popcorn shrimp are all winners. The towels instead of napkins is a cute, casual touch. I ate at Virgil's twice during my last trip to NY and will be sure to return on every trip in the future.
Pros: Polite service, great food
Cons: Crowded bar
more