The Prix Fixe is a total bargain and can't be beat, but our tab ended up being $100 or so because we got a little careless with ordering the wine.  What motivated me to go to Gavroche was a TimeOut review saying that one of the chefs is from Troisgros in Lyon.  It was totally worth it.  Every single thing was great, especially the steak frites- they got the sauce just right.  The service was great - I wasn't expecting much in terms of service (two kids in bluejeans with backpacks), but they treated us very well.
Pros:  Excellent food, Very good service, Prix Fixe @ $19!
Cons:  Can't think of any
                        
more