This is the first time I went to this restaurant, we were seated upstairs where I think is not as romantic as downstairs. So next time you may wanna request for a table downstairs. The place is nicely decorated and romantic. Service is not exceptionally good but decent. We had a 5 course tasting menu and all of them were great. I wouldn't say that the place is really the ""most"" romantic restaurant in nyc, but it is definitely worth a visit if you've never been there. The price is reasonable with all the great things. My girlfriend loved the place. The only cons is that the tables are located too closely, like the other person said, you could seat closer to someone you don't know than your lover.
Pros: Romantic, Good food, Famous
Cons: Bit crowded
more