I haven't been to any of the other top BBQ places in nyc, but that's fine with me. This place is really good!
Every time i've been to Virgil's, it's been at an off hour either in the afternoon or late evening -- so i've never had difficulty getting a table. I'd imagine it's a lot more difficult during lunch/dinner hours.
Although none of the menu prices are expensive considering the quantity and quality, i'd say that the best value can probably be had in getting one of their sandwiches -- i.e. the ham or pulled pork. You'll get at least a half a pound (probably more) of their amazing bbq'd meats for about 9 bucks.
Definitely highly recommended.
Pros: quantity, quality, taste
more