The food is really very good. I've been told their salads are all great, but I'm not much on salad. I am big on steak, though, and Tavern's is really good. I was surprised by the fries you can order with it - they were true shoestring fries, extremely thin, and had a very good seasoning salt (though they could've stood to put a bit more on there!). The service is okay, but I usually go midafternoon on Saturdays, when they only have one or two waiters for their whole dining area, and I usually eat outside (highly recommended if it's warm/cool enough!), so I suppose it could just be me. The lighting is almost too dim, but that's nice for dinner.
Pros: Good food, ambiance
Cons: Sparse service, dim lighting other than for dinner
more