top 10

Cattlemans Steakhouse & Fish

Claim
marker

140 Mount Rushmore Rd
Custer, SD 57730

marker
(605) 673-4402
Incorrect info? Correct your listing
Main categories:

Restaurants

,

Steak Houses

Related categories:

Food & Dining

Photos
Cattlemans Steakhouse & Fish - Custer, SD
Cattlemans Steakhouse & Fish - Custer, SD
Reviews
( 56 )
( 0 )
( 0 )
( 0 )
( 0 )

Best

Best restaurant in South Dakota!?

Worst

All reviews seem positive

Ordered the Ribeye that had way too 8/10/2012

Ordered the Ribeye that had way too much fat and grisle. It may have been 100% Angus but that cow must have been in poor condition prior to slaughter. Also the only vegetable choice was corn on the cob with no substitute available. The breakfast is good but almost $40 for a meal that was mediocre at best is not worth it. Two out of 5 stars. more
Reply | Report abuse |

We will definitely Return 10/12/2010

This is was a dining experience well worth repeating. more
Reply | Report abuse |

The Best in The STATE 10/4/2010

Best restaurant in South Dakota!? more
Reply | Report abuse |

Very delicious food!? 10/1/2010

Very delicious food!? more
Reply | Report abuse |

Very Good Food 9/28/2010

We ate twice at the Cattleman's Steakhouse. We found the food to be very good. When we ate dinner there, the food was cooked as we wished. We found the waiter to be very efficient. The second time we ate there, we had a young lady that spoke limited English. We enjoyed her-she tried very hard to please and kept an eye on us. I wouldn't hesitate to eat there again. Prices were also reasonable.? more
Reply | Report abuse |

That's some good stuff, dude 9/24/2010

My husband and I still stop by every time we're in the area for their bison steak. I'm not a connoisseur, being practically vegetarian except for my curious addiction to bison, shrimp, and salmon, but that's some good stuff, dude. Especially after a six mile hike in the state park, which is usually the condition we visit this place in. :) more
Reply | Report abuse |

Great meal!! 9/22/2010

The wife and I ate supper there tonight. I had a 10 oz prime rib with a baked potato and the wife had the steak fillet with a baked potato. We both had our steaks cooked to medium-rare. We both had wine with the meal and a ""turtle puff"" for dessert. The steaks were done to perfection, the wine and dessert excellent. The service was top-notch. The place was packed and everyone seemed to be having a great time. The facilities were immaculate. There's no doubt that we'll be going back again very soon!? more
Reply | Report abuse |

A great big ""WOW"" 9/17/2010

First of all we barely got in the door and we were greeted and shown to out table!! The server showed up almost immediately to take our drink order. Very professional staff. Our food was delicious and my coffee cup never went empty...I love that!! My husbands steak was perfect and the server did not leave the food without asking if it looked good and then came back a few minutes later to ask if it tasted okay. Just great place all the way around. Very clean, great atmosphere, and the prices were very good! The gift show was nice as well. Confusion over a price but other than that the whole place was great to us. We returned for breakfast and another dinner while we were in the area!! more
Reply | Report abuse |

Excellent service 9/10/2010

I received prompt, courteous service by the server. more
Reply | Report abuse |

We will return 9/7/2010

This is was a dining experience well worth repeating. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Dinner was excellent 8/25/2010

The rib dinner was delicious!? more
Reply | Report abuse |

A wonderful experience 8/11/2010

The steaks are incredibly delicious and tender. Dining at the Cattlemen’s is more than just eating a good meal- it is a wonderful experience. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Consistenly outstanding 8/6/2010

Been going there for years. Consistently outstanding. Without a doubt the best steak quality and best preparation anywhere around. And the baked potatoes melt in your mouth. more
Reply | Report abuse |

The best! 8/4/2010

This is by far the best steakhouse. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Friendly staff! 8/2/2010

A decent burger joint. No real complains here. Nothing out of the ordinary. Friendly staff! more
Reply | Report abuse |

Great meal!!! 7/27/2010

The wife and I ate supper there tonight. I had a 10 oz prime rib with a baked potato and the wife had the steak fillet with a baked potato. We both had our steaks cooked to medium-rare. We both had wine with the meal and a ""turtle puff"" for dessert. The steaks were done to perfection, the wine and dessert excellent. The service was top-notch. The place was packed and everyone seemed to be having a great time. The facilities were immaculate. There's no doubt that we'll be going back again very soon!? more
Reply | Report abuse |

We can't wait to go back 7/23/2010

very nice resturant.Good service and very good food. more
Reply | Report abuse |

LOVE Cattlemans Custer 7/21/2010

We arrived late (9pm), with a large (9) group ages 9 to 45.. the menu had something for everyone, including pasta, bbq, seafood, and we loved it all. service was excellent and the gift shop was actually entertaining for at least 45 minutes for the whole group! more
Reply | Report abuse |

We stop by every time we're in the area 7/19/2010

My husband and I still stop by every time we're in the area for their bison steak. I'm not a connoisseur, being practically vegetarian except for my curious addiction to bison, shrimp, and salmon, but that's some good stuff, dude. Especially after a six mile hike in the state park, which is usually the condition we visit this place in. :) more
Reply | Report abuse |
< Previous 1 2 Next >
Menu for Cattlemans Steakhouse & Fish


Summer SALE!!!:
15% OFF all yearly plans
Use year15 at checkout. Expires 1/1/2021
badge