There are very few good gyms on Staten Island. This one is right down the block from my house and has very good free weights and big, hardcore guys. Plenty of cardio equipment although it is crammed in a little tightly. But the focus here is really on lifting. The guest fee can't be beat. The women's locker room leaves much to be desired, however, and they should stop charging for lockers, get bigger ones, and let you bring in your own locks.
Pros: parking, cheap, hardcore
Cons: , crammed cardio, bad lockers