I know what you're thinking because it's the same thing I've been thinking all these years. This small diner is a staple on the East end of the island, mainly for the $3.99 breakfast (not available on holidays or weekends). The food isn't bad (similar to a Denny's or IHOP), but it's considerably closer to those @ Fish Village than the other mentioned diners.
Bottom Line: Food OK, Price just right.
more