Archie McPhee is truly an outfitter of popular (and unpopular) culture. If you stop in, make sure you have at least an hour to look around.
Some of the stuff you can get: enough Tiki theme items to outfit an entire room, tiny glass bottles reminiscent of old medicine dispensaries, tin lunchboxes warning you of the dangers of syphilis, and fighting alien puppets. They have drawers upon drawers filled with little plastic figures and spare parts from electronic and mechanical gadgets, which are great for the budding artist in you. It definitely caters to your inner geek too, with such gifts as the Internet urinal and coke bottle glasses.
Finally, if someone you know has never gotten over the action figures of their youth, you can set them up with so many quirky action figures that they'll never tire of them (especially since they come out with more all the time). Shushing librarian, barista (with interchangeable heads), Cleopatra, Sigmund Freud, male nurse, and much much more.
The home decorating annex across the parking lot from the main store is pretty cool, but most of the stuff is not affordable to your average shopper (many large decorative items cost several hundred dollars). Do check out the sheet materials in the back and the less expensive home decorating items though.
more