Since I was a little kid, Napoli's Pizza has been a real favorite of me and my family. Ever though there are three other family owned pizzerias, whenever I come back to Tiffin, Napoli is our top choice. Since we still have two families locally and my parents in Tiffin, we order Napoli's for every family gathering, especially Christmas!
The staff couldn't be nicer and are always willing to accommodate our family in their didning room (now numbering 20 but has been as large as 30).
Like the previous reviewer, we love the foldovers and the beer is always cold. Treat yourself to Napoli when you're in the Tiffin area. It's worth the drive!