I had to post a newer review especially since there are a couple less than flattering. The service was friendly and impeccable without being annoying. The restaurant was spotless (including restrooms) and the linens were starched, clean and crisp white.
The food was very good. We arrived early and took advantage of the "Dining for Two" option (all inclusive price which included soup served in a large tureen that was left at the table, salad, hot delicious bread, entrée, dessert, and beverage or wine). Both of us had the Manicotti, but the waiter said we could each get something different. They were very accommodating and graciously agreed to a special order item that was not on the menu. The sauce tasted fresh and the meatballs were good (perhaps pre-fab? but good).
Later in the evening we drove by and the place was packed. I would highly recommend Romanello's. I know we'll be back!