I believe the reviewer has missed her mark. Rudy's atmosphere is both quaint and cozy and does have windows in both the bar area as well as the restaurant area. I question her ability to judge the meal if she can't even see the windows. Anyway, this well established restaurant has been a cornerstone in Cliffside Park and provides the best calamari this side of Italy. I suggest the reviewer purchase a pair of eyeglasses and perhaps acquire a sense of taste!