The 3 stars come from the atmosphere. It is really fun to be at Emmy's. The staff is friendly and "hip" and they always play great music in there. The spaghetti and meatballs are fair. The meatballs are on the verge of being ammunition for a small canon but its ok. The sauce is good. Wine list is ok. Beer are in bottles. The Cucumber martini's not so good.
The food is not that spectacular but I'd go back for the fun atmostphere.