Based on the two reviews on this site I chose Tucker Tire Co. to fix my flat.
At once I was greeted and asked to pull my car forward to the work area. I was greeted by a man that immediately offered me a used tire and I let him know I'd like my flat one fixed if the damage wasn't on the sidewall.
It turns out the damage WAS on the sidewall. The man fetched a like new tire that he immediately balanced and installed (including new air stem) for an even $15.
I liked the simplicity and speed with which they work.
Not the cleanest or most professional place, but they sure do tires right.