I am quite pleased overall. I thought they might have done a slightly better job of protecting my annual & perennial flower beds (draping and such) than they did, and we have found nails that their magnet bar missed, but all my friends who have had a roof replaced said we would. So really no surprises. Also Eclipse roofing accepted my Angie's List coupon which I printed off the web site and saved me $300 (discounted) from the original bid. This $300 savings will pay for my continued Angie's List subscription for this year and several more.