Poppa Mias has Italian ices in lots and lots of flavors. You can buy a single ice, or a pint of your favorite flavor. They are open only from Memorial Day to Labor day, and are always crammed with locals! Located on the side of Montauk Highway in what looks like a shabby shack, they are easy to over look. Don’t be fooled, some of the best ices around can be found at this humble, family run stand.