Well for starters jimmy johns in neenah is on tullar road not west college avenue. West college avenue is in appleton. that aside, jimmy johns was a good sub. Not great but adequate. What i really loved was their iced tea machine. It makes the tea while you are there, similar to teazers at Quick Trip stores. I am an iced tea fanatic,and i was impressed with their freshly brewed tea. I would go there just for the tea if nothing else. I would give 5 stars just on that alone, but that is not what jimmy johns is primarily noted for by the general public. Also the day i was there, they had a bad problem with flies. That was kind of a culinary turn off. But it is that time of year and many restaurants locally seem to have the same problem. It shouldnt be a problem most of the time.