Cosimo's isn't the place you'd expect to find next to Wal Mart and Home Depot, but give it a try and you will be pleased. Whether you decide on a brick oven pizza or one of their large pasta dishes, you will be pleased. The creativity used at this Italian eatery stands out from the Newburgh crowd. It's Italian with a twist, in my opinion. I agree that both the wine list and the list of cocktails (Cosimo's has great martinis!) are extensive, with some higher end choices included. I've never gotten around to dessert at Cosimo's because I"ve always been so full from bread and my entree.