The Dining room is one of two nice restaurants in Staunton - and the menu prices reflect this! I have had the opportunity to eat lunch at The Dining Room and it was absolutely delicious! If you want fresh bread before your meal, call ahead or order it the minute you sit down...it takes a long time to heat it up for some reason!
They have a great bar tender there that mixes a perfect drink. You'll primarily find Staunton business people dining there at the lunch hour. I have never been there for dinner, so I'm not quite sure what the crowd is like in the evenings.