Pizza is a great option for New Years Eve. They are open and delivering late and it keeps you from having to go out on the road if you have them deliver. Domino's Pizza is usually lower cost and still a good quality. They often run a 5+5+5 deal that's easy to please everyone. It's medium pizzas with one topping each. They also have side orders as well.
It is a small location and for delivery or carry out only. Phone and walk in orders are both easy to place. Picking up is easy as well. I haven't tried their delivery service. I have never had an issue with quality.