It's really hard to beat the Blackbird, which is a short walk from the ferry terminal in downtown Winslow / Bainbridge Island.
Pros: Cinnamon rols and orange rolls are unbelievable, but the local fav is the lemon-blackberry scone. Big, fluffy, with lots of fruit and flavor. The best deal in the house is toast -- thick slices of homemade oat-wheat bread with raspberry freezer jam for $1.25.
Cons: Somewhat limited seating inside, but plenty of casual outdoor seating -- some covered -- right on the main drag.
Do what the locals do -- come early on Saturday morning, have coffee and a baked good, then walk a block up the hill to the Saturday Farmers Market.
more