Located just off the circle in downtown Sebring, unwrap the Party is a small to medium sized shop that specializes in party supplies. I like to patronize locally owned businesses whenever possible and Unwrap the Party makes this easy to do. They have a nice selection of items at reasonable prices. (Not cheap, but reasonable.)
For a football party, they sell invitations, cups, plates, table covers, party picks (like for meatballs or sandwiches), party trays and banners. They also have balloons that are either shaped like a football or have an NFL design.
The staff is always friendly and helpful, too.