City Barbeque was an instant success in Gahanna, but their original location kind of sucked. The new store is in a great location, very visible. The food is good, down-home cooking and the prices are affordable. They do catering (whole pig, anyone?) and have a dining room and carryout. The dining room is rather barn-like, which isn't my favorite style, but it suits the place.
http://www.citybarbeque.com/
more