Webster Hall was never one of the best clubs in NY but it's gotten progressively worse over the past few years. My friends and I used to frequent the club before we turned 21 because it was one of the few places with a college night. The lines were not too long, the music was good, and there were a ton of options.
Since then they've gone under a reconstruction that took far too long and made the lower floor half its normal size for months, they no longer play reggae or Latin music (now there is only a techno and Top 40 room), and they have been attracting the wrong crowd. On one night there is a crude, amateur strip tease on the main floor and on another night there's an open mic for local rappers who bring all sorts of riff raff as fans. I also hear that they scam local artists and promoters, so be careful if doing business with this club.
I would probably only return for a concert which I hear is one of the few things they do well.
Pros: Free for ladies on Thursday nights
Cons: Bad sound system and crowd, extremely crowded
more