I think that this place has the best desserts around, especially cheesecake. Their haloumi burger is unrivaled (although, the quality of it seems slightly random -- during the evening it seems you have a better chance of a good one). Their souvlaki is great as well. I tried a very Greek sounding dish which included loukaniko ham and haloumi, and it ended up being the only one I didn't even finish (rare for me).
I go here on occasion and have never been disappointed. One of the reviews below did make me worried -- it's not at all the Athens Cafe I know.
Pros: Most of the food I've had here is delicious.
Cons: I haven't encountered any
more