I went to I Cugini last Saturday night for dinner and the food was pretty awful.  My date and I shared the grilled Calamari and it was gross.  I've had grilled Calamari before and although nothing compares to it being fried, their version tasted bad.  We then shared a Cesar salad and it was fine.  We also split the Shirmp Risotto and it had like a sandy grit (sand maybe) in it.  We sent it back.  The manager was super friendly and felt horrible and asked if we wanted to order anything else.  Since the cooked food was so bad we said no.  He then sent over a delicious chocolate desert - best thing we had the entire meal.  I would never go back as there are too many good restaurants in Santa Monica and our meal tasted pretty terrible.  Interestingly the restaurant was packed.
Pros:  The Manager was nice and wanted to fix our issue
Cons:  tasteless food, patio was quite loud
                        
more