Ever since my friend and I discovered Fish, after exiting The Blind Tiger across the street (a good companion to the Fish experience, with a huge beer selection and GREAT bar food!), we have been going back constantly for two and a half years. I have been there almost a hundred times now without exaggeration, and have gotten a few of my friends addicted to the place too! I'm still drawn to the oyster/clam special, but I haven't had anything on the menu that wasn't great! I wish there was more bar space, because the staff is awesome and friendly, but they've added a little counter space on the outside which is also excellent. Jesus is a great shucker, and their oysters and clams are unbeatable (eight bucks gets you half a dozen of them, including a drink!!). Their entrees and their soups and even their SIDES are top notch, and you must check out their Bleecker St. Burger. I may go there for New Year's Eve, it's just such a comfortable vibe.
Pros: The entire menu, the staff, the music, the vibe
Cons: None. Seriously!
more