I ordered a medium and small pizza from their menupages menu. And when I went to pick it up they had a very large and medium size pizzas waiting on me, wanting to charge me over $36. I explained that I had only ordered a medium and small, which were cheaper on their online menu. They said that they offered no small size, only large and medium and personal (which the person I ordered with on the phone never mentioned, or corrected me on). They argued in front of me for a while and then eventually took a measly $2 off the bill! Although it was way too much pizza and cost way too much, I would have been happy if the pizza was actually good. It was not. It was extremely greasy and soggy and the meat smelled weird. I would NEVER go back to Carmines, nor would I recommend it to anyone. Here's a tip Carmine...a little bit of customer service goes a long way.
Cons: Terrible service, terrible pizza!
more