I've been to the Comedy Cellar several times and have never been disappointed. You should definitely call to reserve your tickets and get in line early to ensure a good seat. You pay only $10 a person but agree to purchase two menu items as well. (Try the burgers- delicious! Drinks are also great).
The thing I love about COmedy Cellar is you never know the lineup of comedians. Some nights Ray Romano will stop in! I've typically seen nobodys, but they are so funny! Once, Colin Quinn graced us with his drunken presence. He was terribly unfunny, I couldn't believe he ever made it in show business.
The host/ emcee is Ardie Fuqua and he is always funny- fresh material, welcoming stage presence and great one-liners. Check it out, Ardie's worth it by himself!
Pros: in the heart of the village
Cons: service is pretty average
more